How to Appeal an Inspection Decision

Small Meat Processors August 28, 2013 Print Friendly and PDF

If you are a meat processor, and you believe your inspector has given you an "NR" or noncompliance record that is unwarranted or an  error, you have the right to appeal the inspector's decision.  Many processors are hesitant to appeal, for fear of damaging their relationship with their FSIS inspector .  However, FSIS emphasizes that processors should not fear retaliation if they choose to appeal. 

Small meat processors who are members of the NMPAN Listserve and have utilized the appeal process say that it works well and offer this advice:  

  • Use the appeal process sparingly, but don't hesitate to use it if you feel you are correct. 
  • Never make it emotional or personal.  Stick to facts, regulations and science. 
  • Follow the chain of command and fully expect that it is going to go through your inspector, the IIC (Inspector-in-Charge) and the FLS (Frontline Supervisor) if not beyond that.  The appeal process can be slow and time-consuming, so be ready to exercise patience! 

For more information, consult FSIS's Compliance Guideline for Small and Very Small Plants Appealing Inspection Decisions as well as this article from Food Safety News "How to Appeal FSIS Noncompliance Records."

 

Welcome

This is where you can find research-based information from America's land-grant universities enabled by eXtension.org

LOCATE

USDA / NIFA

This work is supported by the USDA National Institute of Food and Agriculture, New Technologies for Ag Extension project.